November 2026 | 

Passion and Discipline: Build Social Ventures That Work

Passion Plus Discipline: Building a Social Venture That Works

On paper, the idea behind TOMS Shoes was hard to argue with: for every pair of shoes a customer bought, the company would give a pair to a child who needed them. “It seems self-evident that giving shoes to children who don't have them can only do good,” says Tyler Wry, associate professor of management at Wharton. When, to its credit, TOMS examined the evidence, the picture was more complicated. Free shoes undercut local shoemakers, who suddenly had a much thinner market for their products. Handouts risked creating dependency rather than agency. And people who needed shoes, it turned out, already had ways to get them.

Wry sees versions of that story often. “There are many entrepreneurs who see problems in the world and want to solve them, and they think the market will rise to meet their good intentions,” he says. “As much as we’d like that to be true, there’s just very little evidence to support it. If you don’t have a strong business case, it’s going to be incredibly difficult to bring anything to market, to drive customer adoption, to get financing.”

Getting that balance right matters more as the field grows. Social enterprise is no longer a niche: more than 10 million of these ventures now generate an estimated $2 trillion a year, according to the World Economic Forum, and the Global Impact Investing Network estimates that the impact investing market has passed $1 trillion in assets under management. Those ventures, and the investors backing them, need founders who can make both the mission and the business work. A new online elective in Wharton Executive Education's Entrepreneurship Certificate program, The Impact Venture Playbook: Opportunity, Evidence, Model, Capital, is designed to develop them. It is led by Wry, who directs the Wharton Impact Investing Research Lab, is a founding partner at Critical Venture Partners (an early-stage impact investing fund), and studies ventures that pursue commercial and social goals at the same time.


“
Every entrepreneur needs passion. But passion without discipline is a gamble. Maybe it works, but it probably won’t. What you want is passion married to discipline."
Tyler Wry, PhD
Associate Professor of Management; Faculty Director, Impact Investing Research Lab, The Wharton School; Faculty Director for Social Entrepreneurship, UPenn Venture Lab

Passion Plus Discipline

Wry is quick to say that the course is not an argument against caring deeply. “Passion is really important,” he says. “It's going to make you persist and work harder and try to get it right.” But the same conviction that keeps a founder going can make it hard to hear bad or conflicting news. When an idea feels like a personal mission, criticism can sound like an attack on the cause itself, and evidence that something isn’t working is easier to explain away. “A founder who stops listening stops learning,” Wry says. “Instead of testing and refining the idea, they push what they believe the market wants rather than what the evidence shows it will actually reward.”

That risk is common to all entrepreneurs, Wry says, but the stakes are arguably higher when the goal is to help people. “Launching an idea just because you've fallen in love with it rarely does anything for you, for the people you want to serve, or for the planet,” he explains. “Every entrepreneur needs passion. But passion without discipline is a gamble. Maybe it works, but it probably won’t. What you want is passion married to discipline.”

The course is designed to show what that discipline looks like — Wry calls it “an underlying process that’s rigorous and intentional about how you build” — and provide opportunities to apply it. Over two self-paced modules and a culminating project, participants take one issue they care about and develop it into a venture they can evaluate, test, and defend.

Making Impact Prove Itself

One of the first tools learners build is an impact model, a framework USAID developed to bring more rigor to measuring what international development programs actually achieve. It has since spread to nonprofits and, increasingly, to social enterprises. The model asks a simple question: if a venture intends to create a certain impact, what has to be true for that to happen? It traces the logic step by step, from the resources a venture needs, to the activities it carries out, to the products and services it delivers, to the short- and medium-term outcomes those produce, and finally to the broader impact the founder hopes to achieve.

“Impact isn’t always self-evident,” Wry says. “There are a lot of times where impact doesn’t manifest, or where it actually creates negative outcomes.” He describes a venture that his investment fund considered and ultimately passed on. The company aimed to help students in two-year programs transfer to four-year universities. Some 80 percent of those students want to make that move, Wry notes, but only a small fraction do. The mission was compelling. But the risk was that students who transferred and then didn’t finish would end up worse off, with more debt and still no degree, and the evidence suggested dropout rates for this group were high. “The founder is really impact oriented and is trying to mitigate it,” Wry says, “but I saw too much risk.”

In the second module, learners put their own ideas under the same kind of scrutiny. They strengthen the impact model with indicators and evidence; build a Business Model Canvas; and work through the trade-offs between the two, including the common situation in which the people who pay for a venture are not the people who benefit from it. They then identify the assumptions that matter most, design tests for them, and consider which kinds of funding fit.

AI can speed that work considerably. Assembling the evidence behind an impact model, Wry says, has gone from a weeklong project to an afternoon, and building a landing page to test demand is far faster than it used to be. Founders can even ask an AI tool to take on the persona of a customer or beneficiary for a first round of feedback before talking to real people. Wry has seen impact-minded entrepreneurs avoid these tools out of concern for their effects on people and the planet, and he thinks that is a mistake. “The data centers and LLMs are going to be built, and people are going to use them for all sorts of not-so-desirable purposes,” he says. “To the extent we can use them to fight the good fight, we should.”

A Stake in the Ground

The course ends with a decision rather than a business plan. For the final project, learners prepare either a Venture Decision Brief, which recommends and defends what the venture should do next, or a Venture Review Packet, which readies it for scrutiny by an advisor, accelerator, funder, or leadership team. Continuing is one possible answer. So are changing direction, testing further, and stopping.

“This is a stake in the ground. This is your ante into the game,” Wry says. “You’re not at the stage where it’s time to start building and go out and raise money. You’re at the stage where you need to be a world-class expert on what you’re building and why, or else you’re not going to build something anyone wants.” Few ventures end up looking like their founder’s first plan, he adds. “This is a learning journey. It’s hard, because there are a lot of variables and things move really fast. If it was easy, someone would have done it already.”

The course is for aspiring and early-stage social entrepreneurs, and also for people who develop impact-oriented products inside companies and institutions or who support ventures as investors, advisors, and accelerator staff. Learners who complete the required work earn a digital credential, recognizing skills in critical thinking, judgment and decision making, business planning, impact measurement, and venture experimentation.

Whether they go on to launch a venture or apply what they learn inside an organization, participants leave with a habit TOMS eventually adopted: testing good intentions against evidence and changing course when that evidence calls for it. In 2019, the company retired its one-for-one model and began giving a share of its profits to grassroots organizations instead. For Wry, that kind of evolution is the point. “Think of any venture as something living, breathing, and evolving,” he says. “Be passionate about the problem you want to solve, and disciplined enough to keep testing, learning, and adjusting until you find a solution that actually solves it.”